1
Points
Questions
0
Answers
22
-
Asked on June 3, 2021 in Meaning.
I think it’s a form of the imperfect in English. Why the modal “would” is the past tense of “will”, but, as a past tense, it often functions as the English equivalent of the imperfect tense, which has its own inflectional form in many Romance languages. I think it is the past tense of “will” and acting as an imperfect. In this case, in a dream, in this instance, I consider it as the example of act by imperfect. When someone is elbowed on ribs, the wind is usually out of his or his mouth. In essence, it is attempting to convey this notion. When Harry was elbowed in the ribs, he would let out the normal audible gasp.
JK Rowling did not have to use the past tense of “will” (would) here; she could just have said, “He let out an audible gasp” and it would have been fine. I was just told she used the past tense of “will” for style here. We’re not sure why and why not, all her posts for this sentence are similar. I’m just amazed that she doesn’t have a strong past tense here?
How can I help you here? I know her use of “would” sounds fine to my native ears and there’s nothing wrong with the Rowling’s grammar in this sentence; it’s just her style coming out in the ink in my mind.
- 559300 views
- 16 answers
- 206758 votes
-
Asked on June 3, 2021 in Meaning.
I think it’s a form of the imperfect in English. Why the modal “would” is the past tense of “will”, but, as a past tense, it often functions as the English equivalent of the imperfect tense, which has its own inflectional form in many Romance languages. I think it is the past tense of “will” and acting as an imperfect. In this case, in a dream, in this instance, I consider it as the example of act by imperfect. When someone is elbowed on ribs, the wind is usually out of his or his mouth. In essence, it is attempting to convey this notion. When Harry was elbowed in the ribs, he would let out the normal audible gasp.
JK Rowling did not have to use the past tense of “will” (would) here; she could just have said, “He let out an audible gasp” and it would have been fine. I was just told she used the past tense of “will” for style here. We’re not sure why and why not, all her posts for this sentence are similar. I’m just amazed that she doesn’t have a strong past tense here?
How can I help you here? I know her use of “would” sounds fine to my native ears and there’s nothing wrong with the Rowling’s grammar in this sentence; it’s just her style coming out in the ink in my mind.
- 559300 views
- 16 answers
- 206758 votes
-
Asked on June 2, 2021 in Meaning.
I think it’s a form of the imperfect in English. Why the modal “would” is the past tense of “will”, but, as a past tense, it often functions as the English equivalent of the imperfect tense, which has its own inflectional form in many Romance languages. I think it is the past tense of “will” and acting as an imperfect. In this case, in a dream, in this instance, I consider it as the example of act by imperfect. When someone is elbowed on ribs, the wind is usually out of his or his mouth. In essence, it is attempting to convey this notion. When Harry was elbowed in the ribs, he would let out the normal audible gasp.
JK Rowling did not have to use the past tense of “will” (would) here; she could just have said, “He let out an audible gasp” and it would have been fine. I was just told she used the past tense of “will” for style here. We’re not sure why and why not, all her posts for this sentence are similar. I’m just amazed that she doesn’t have a strong past tense here?
How can I help you here? I know her use of “would” sounds fine to my native ears and there’s nothing wrong with the Rowling’s grammar in this sentence; it’s just her style coming out in the ink in my mind.
- 559300 views
- 16 answers
- 206758 votes
-
Asked on June 2, 2021 in Meaning.
I think it’s a form of the imperfect in English. Why the modal “would” is the past tense of “will”, but, as a past tense, it often functions as the English equivalent of the imperfect tense, which has its own inflectional form in many Romance languages. I think it is the past tense of “will” and acting as an imperfect. In this case, in a dream, in this instance, I consider it as the example of act by imperfect. When someone is elbowed on ribs, the wind is usually out of his or his mouth. In essence, it is attempting to convey this notion. When Harry was elbowed in the ribs, he would let out the normal audible gasp.
JK Rowling did not have to use the past tense of “will” (would) here; she could just have said, “He let out an audible gasp” and it would have been fine. I was just told she used the past tense of “will” for style here. We’re not sure why and why not, all her posts for this sentence are similar. I’m just amazed that she doesn’t have a strong past tense here?
How can I help you here? I know her use of “would” sounds fine to my native ears and there’s nothing wrong with the Rowling’s grammar in this sentence; it’s just her style coming out in the ink in my mind.
- 559300 views
- 16 answers
- 206758 votes
-
Asked on June 1, 2021 in Meaning.
I think it’s a form of the imperfect in English. Why the modal “would” is the past tense of “will”, but, as a past tense, it often functions as the English equivalent of the imperfect tense, which has its own inflectional form in many Romance languages. I think it is the past tense of “will” and acting as an imperfect. In this case, in a dream, in this instance, I consider it as the example of act by imperfect. When someone is elbowed on ribs, the wind is usually out of his or his mouth. In essence, it is attempting to convey this notion. When Harry was elbowed in the ribs, he would let out the normal audible gasp.
JK Rowling did not have to use the past tense of “will” (would) here; she could just have said, “He let out an audible gasp” and it would have been fine. I was just told she used the past tense of “will” for style here. We’re not sure why and why not, all her posts for this sentence are similar. I’m just amazed that she doesn’t have a strong past tense here?
How can I help you here? I know her use of “would” sounds fine to my native ears and there’s nothing wrong with the Rowling’s grammar in this sentence; it’s just her style coming out in the ink in my mind.
- 559300 views
- 16 answers
- 206758 votes
-
Asked on June 1, 2021 in Meaning.
I think it’s a form of the imperfect in English. Why the modal “would” is the past tense of “will”, but, as a past tense, it often functions as the English equivalent of the imperfect tense, which has its own inflectional form in many Romance languages. I think it is the past tense of “will” and acting as an imperfect. In this case, in a dream, in this instance, I consider it as the example of act by imperfect. When someone is elbowed on ribs, the wind is usually out of his or his mouth. In essence, it is attempting to convey this notion. When Harry was elbowed in the ribs, he would let out the normal audible gasp.
JK Rowling did not have to use the past tense of “will” (would) here; she could just have said, “He let out an audible gasp” and it would have been fine. I was just told she used the past tense of “will” for style here. We’re not sure why and why not, all her posts for this sentence are similar. I’m just amazed that she doesn’t have a strong past tense here?
How can I help you here? I know her use of “would” sounds fine to my native ears and there’s nothing wrong with the Rowling’s grammar in this sentence; it’s just her style coming out in the ink in my mind.
- 559300 views
- 16 answers
- 206758 votes
-
Asked on May 31, 2021 in Meaning.
I think it’s a form of the imperfect in English. Why the modal “would” is the past tense of “will”, but, as a past tense, it often functions as the English equivalent of the imperfect tense, which has its own inflectional form in many Romance languages. I think it is the past tense of “will” and acting as an imperfect. In this case, in a dream, in this instance, I consider it as the example of act by imperfect. When someone is elbowed on ribs, the wind is usually out of his or his mouth. In essence, it is attempting to convey this notion. When Harry was elbowed in the ribs, he would let out the normal audible gasp.
JK Rowling did not have to use the past tense of “will” (would) here; she could just have said, “He let out an audible gasp” and it would have been fine. I was just told she used the past tense of “will” for style here. We’re not sure why and why not, all her posts for this sentence are similar. I’m just amazed that she doesn’t have a strong past tense here?
How can I help you here? I know her use of “would” sounds fine to my native ears and there’s nothing wrong with the Rowling’s grammar in this sentence; it’s just her style coming out in the ink in my mind.
- 559300 views
- 16 answers
- 206758 votes
-
Asked on May 30, 2021 in Meaning.
I think it’s a form of the imperfect in English. Why the modal “would” is the past tense of “will”, but, as a past tense, it often functions as the English equivalent of the imperfect tense, which has its own inflectional form in many Romance languages. I think it is the past tense of “will” and acting as an imperfect. In this case, in a dream, in this instance, I consider it as the example of act by imperfect. When someone is elbowed on ribs, the wind is usually out of his or his mouth. In essence, it is attempting to convey this notion. When Harry was elbowed in the ribs, he would let out the normal audible gasp.
JK Rowling did not have to use the past tense of “will” (would) here; she could just have said, “He let out an audible gasp” and it would have been fine. I was just told she used the past tense of “will” for style here. We’re not sure why and why not, all her posts for this sentence are similar. I’m just amazed that she doesn’t have a strong past tense here?
How can I help you here? I know her use of “would” sounds fine to my native ears and there’s nothing wrong with the Rowling’s grammar in this sentence; it’s just her style coming out in the ink in my mind.
- 559300 views
- 16 answers
- 206758 votes
-
Asked on May 30, 2021 in Meaning.
I think it’s a form of the imperfect in English. Why the modal “would” is the past tense of “will”, but, as a past tense, it often functions as the English equivalent of the imperfect tense, which has its own inflectional form in many Romance languages. I think it is the past tense of “will” and acting as an imperfect. In this case, in a dream, in this instance, I consider it as the example of act by imperfect. When someone is elbowed on ribs, the wind is usually out of his or his mouth. In essence, it is attempting to convey this notion. When Harry was elbowed in the ribs, he would let out the normal audible gasp.
JK Rowling did not have to use the past tense of “will” (would) here; she could just have said, “He let out an audible gasp” and it would have been fine. I was just told she used the past tense of “will” for style here. We’re not sure why and why not, all her posts for this sentence are similar. I’m just amazed that she doesn’t have a strong past tense here?
How can I help you here? I know her use of “would” sounds fine to my native ears and there’s nothing wrong with the Rowling’s grammar in this sentence; it’s just her style coming out in the ink in my mind.
- 559300 views
- 16 answers
- 206758 votes
-
Asked on May 29, 2021 in Meaning.
I think it’s a form of the imperfect in English. Why the modal “would” is the past tense of “will”, but, as a past tense, it often functions as the English equivalent of the imperfect tense, which has its own inflectional form in many Romance languages. I think it is the past tense of “will” and acting as an imperfect. In this case, in a dream, in this instance, I consider it as the example of act by imperfect. When someone is elbowed on ribs, the wind is usually out of his or his mouth. In essence, it is attempting to convey this notion. When Harry was elbowed in the ribs, he would let out the normal audible gasp.
JK Rowling did not have to use the past tense of “will” (would) here; she could just have said, “He let out an audible gasp” and it would have been fine. I was just told she used the past tense of “will” for style here. We’re not sure why and why not, all her posts for this sentence are similar. I’m just amazed that she doesn’t have a strong past tense here?
How can I help you here? I know her use of “would” sounds fine to my native ears and there’s nothing wrong with the Rowling’s grammar in this sentence; it’s just her style coming out in the ink in my mind.
- 559300 views
- 16 answers
- 206758 votes